Creekside Tavern Menu (Update 2025)
Welcome to Creekside Tavern, the hidden gem nestled in the picturesque landscape of Payson, Arizona. This charming establishment invites guests to indulge in a menu brimming with delectable options, from fully loaded Nachos to the mouthwatering Beast Burger. Each dish is crafted with fresh, made-to-order ingredients, ensuring a satisfying dining experience.
The ambience here is cozy and welcoming, with outdoor seating that is perfect for those wishing to enjoy the serene surroundings. Diners have praised the generous portions and reasonable prices, making it an ideal spot to bring your appetite!
- Welcoming service that adds a personal touch to each visit.
- Varied seating options, including fire pits surrounded by nature.
- Unforgettably crispy fries served with house-made ranch.
Whether you're driving through or planning a special occasion, Creekside Tavern is sure to become a favorite stop.
Starters & Appetizers
Creekside Wings
12 for 6pc/ 18 for 12pc Wings tossed in your choice of spicy buffalo, sweet BBQ, sweet chili or our signature Creekside Sauce (spicy & sweet). Comes with ranch, celery, and carrot sticks
Onion Rings
Basket of Fries
Chili Cheese Fries
Tater Tots
NM Hatch Green Chile Cheese Crisp
Chorizo, Green Chile & Cheese Skillet
Creekside Sampler Platter
6 Creekside Wings, 4 Chicken Strips, Quesadilla & Onion Rings
GRILLED CHEESE
American, Cheddar & Swiss Cheese with Choice of Fries -add Bacon 2/ -add Tomato 1
BLT
Bacon, lettuce, tomato, and mayo on choice of bread and choice of side.
Beef Hot Dog
100% beef hot dog on brioche bun. Served with ketchup, mustard, relish, and choice of side. Add chili, cheese, and onions - 2
Firehouse Buffalo Chicken Sandwich
On a buttered brioche bun with bacon and pepper jack cheese and siracha **1 DONATED TO CC FIRE DEPT FOR EACH SANDWICH PURCHASED**
Tavern Grilled Chicken Sandwich
House marinated chicken breast on a buttered brioche bun.
Sandwiches
Burgers
TAVERN BURGER
Prime Ground Chuck Beef Patty on a Brioche Bun Served. Served with Lettuce, Tomato, Grilled Onion & Choice of Cheese. - Add Bacon or Chili 2 each / Mushrooms or Grilled Onions 1 each
MAD JACK BURGER
Prime angus beef patty on a buttered brioche bun, topped with fire roasted green chilis. Served with tavern sauce, lettuce, tomato, onion, choice of cheese, and choice of side. Add bacon or mushrooms - 2 each
Creekside Pizza
San Marzano Tomato Sauce and Mozzarella Cheese on a NY Style Thin Crust - Extra Toppings 1 each: Pepperoni, Sausage, Ham, Mushrooms, Bell Peppers, Black Olives, Pineapple
Pizza - Homemade & Hand Tossed
Salads
Buffalo Chicken Salad
Fried Buffalo Chicken Over a Bed of Fresh Greens. Topped with Red Onions, Diced Tomatoes, & Blue Cheese. Choice of Dressing.
House Salad
Fresh Greens, Cheese, Croutons, Red Onions, Cherry Tomatoes, hard boiled egg, cucumbers, black olives. Choice of Dressing. Add Grilled or Fried Chicken 3
Wedge Salad
Romaine heart split in half and topped with tomatoes, mushrooms, red onions, black olives, cheese, bacon bits, hard boiled egg, and croutons. Ranch dressing and lemon wedge
Filet Mignon Street Tacos
Succulent seasoned diced Filet Mignon street tacos. Topped with onions, cilantro, and guacamole. Served with Spanish rice and slow cooked borracho beans and freshly made salsa (hot or mild)
Shrimp Mojado Tacos
3 succulent shrimp tacos on corn tortillas with melted Oaxaca cheese smothered in mild hatch green chile sauce, served with borracho beans and mexican rice
Guadalajara Style Fish Tacos
3 amazing Guadalajara style fish tacos with cabbage and chipotle honey sauce served with borracho beans and mexican rice
Chef's Favorites
Dinner
8oz Cut Sirloin
Served with a dinner salad, fresh vegetables, and mashed potatoes.
New York Strip Steak 12oz
Aged and cut in house, Angus Prime Beef. Served with a dinner salad, fresh vegetables, and mashed potatoes.
14oz Ribeye Steak
Aged and cut in house, Angus Prime Beef. Served with a dinner salad, fresh vegetables, and mashed potatoes.
Bacon Wrapped Filet Mignonn 8oz
Well trimmed and seasoned 8oz bacon wrapped Aged Angus Filet Mignon. Served with in house mashed potatoes and seasoned vegetables.
Porterhouse Steak 1lb
Creekside King Ribeye Steak 20oz
Hand cut and seasoned to perfection this beautiful 20oz king cut ribeye comes topped with sauteed mushrooms & onions. Side salad, in season vegetables, texas toast and homemade mashed potatoes are served with our favorite steak.
Baby Back Ribs Half Rack
Served with a dinner salad, fresh vegetables, and mashed potatoes.
Baby back Ribs Full Rack
Served with a dinner salad, fresh vegetables, and mashed potatoes.
Chipotle Honey Grilled Chicken Breast
Seasoned Grilled Salmon
Served with vegetables & baked potato
DARK ROAST GOURMET COFFEE
SODA
FRESH BREWED ICED TEA
BUD, BUD LIGHT, MICHELOB ULTRA
IMPORTS & CRAFT BEERS
HOUSE CAB & ZIN RED WINE GLASS
HOUSE CHARDONNAY & SAUVIGNON BLANC GLASS
PREMIUM SPIRITS
CRAFT COCKTAILS
Beverage & Spirits
Breakfast Menu Saturday & Sunday 9am to 11am
Creekside Burrito
Homemade Corn Beef Hash
Creekside Wake Up
2 eggs, choice of meat and choice of toast. Add ribeye for 7
Homemade Buttermilk Pancakes
Homemade Biscuits & Gravy
Creekside Breakfast Sandwich
Texas style toast with 2 eggs, American cheese and your choice of meat - Served with tater tots
Kids Chocolate Chip Pancakes
Mini chocolate chip pancakes with an egg and your choice of meat